As Chris Gilligan wrote last week, it seems like we’re primed for an exciting and drama-filled second half of the season. There are plenty of teams still vying for a postseason berth, and the trade deadline is right around the corner as we head into the All-Star break.
A reminder for how these rankings are calculated: first, we take the three most important components of a team — their offense (wRC+), their pitching (a 50/50 blend of FIP- and RA9-, weighted by starter and reliever IP share), and their defense (RAA) — and combine them to create an overall team quality metric. I also add in a factor for “luck,” adjusting a team’s win percentage based on expected win-loss record. The result is a power ranking, which is then presented in tiers below.
Tier 1 – The Best of the Best
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Braves
56-27
2
123
90
84
-6
160
100.0%
Rays
57-30
-1
126
88
102
6
161
99.3%
Rangers
50-34
-6
122
87
101
11
170
81.7%
Eight is the Braves’ number this year. Not only are they sending eight players to the All-Star game in Seattle next week, but they’re also in the midst of their third eight-game winning streak this season. Incredibly, they lost just four times during the month of June and have now overtaken the Rays for the best record in baseball. They’ve weathered all those injuries to their starting rotation by simply pounding across run after run; since the beginning of June, they’ve scored nearly seven runs per game. They’ll head into the midseason break with a road trip that takes them through Cleveland and then to Tampa Bay to face the team they just passed in the overall standings.
Tier 2 – Solid Contenders
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Diamondbacks
50-35
4
105
101
95
8
134
79.8%
Astros
46-38
-2
102
92
91
8
139
64.9%
Blue Jays
45-40
1
108
96
92
3
142
56.6%
Giants
46-38
0
103
99
93
11
138
67.9%
Dodgers
46-37
-1
110
100
102
0
124
89.3%
Orioles
49-33
6
104
105
87
-10
103
61.3%
Angels
45-41
-1
113
100
95
0
133
33.9%
The Diamondbacks continue to set the pace in the NL West thanks to All-Star–caliber performances from Corbin Carroll, Zac Gallen, Lourdes Gurriel Jr. and an outstanding bounce-back season from Ketel Marte. The latter is one of the biggest snubs on the NL All-Star roster despite being the owner of the second-highest wRC+ among qualified second basemen in the Senior Circuit. Arizona will wrap up the first half of the season with a six-game homestand against the Mets and Pirates.
With a hard-fought win on Sunday, the Astros have taken two of the first three games in a wraparound weekend series against the Rangers to bring them within four games of the division lead and give them seven wins in their last 11 games. That’s a big turnaround after they had lost 11 of their previous 15. After a slow start to the season, José Abreu has finally started contributing offensively, with a 117 wRC+ since hitting his first home run of the season back on May 28.
The Giants couldn’t keep their momentum going last week, losing series to the Blue Jays and the Mets on the road. Luckily for them, the Dodgers only gained a single game on them in the standings after losing two of three to the Royals over the weekend. These two rivals are essentially tied, holding the NL’s final two Wild Card spots. San Francisco is getting a bit healthier — the team activated three players from the IL over the last week and should get Mike Yastrzemski back as soon as Monday — and is finally getting some positive contributions from catcher, as rookie Patrick Bailey has taken the league by storm since being called up in mid-May.
Tier 3 – The Melee
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Yankees
46-38
1
96
104
80
5
102
64.8%
Phillies
44-39
2
101
90
95
-5
117
55.1%
Marlins
48-37
8
97
90
99
-7
89
64.7%
Padres
38-46
-7
101
91
98
17
135
22.0%
Mariners
40-42
-3
100
95
96
9
127
15.8%
Twins
42-43
-4
98
83
90
-13
107
58.6%
Cubs
38-44
-5
99
94
90
4
122
10.6%
Brewers
45-39
5
86
99
99
15
85
59.6%
Reds
45-39
5
98
112
96
-10
58
25.6%
Despite losing their weekend series to the Nationals, the Phillies have been playing some good baseball since the calendar flipped to June, going 18–8 last month to play their way into the middle of the NL Wild Card chase. They’re doing it all despite a prolonged slump from Bryce Harper. They’ve got a tough schedule as they head into the All-Star break: a six-game road trip through Tampa Bay and Miami.
Speaking of the Marlins, they had an up-and-down week after sweeping the Red Sox in Boston and then getting swept by the Braves in Atlanta — a series in which Miami was outscored 29–7. Sandy Alcantara has continued to struggle, which makes the recent success of Eury Pérez, Braxton Garrett, and Jesús Luzardo all the more important.
The Brewers and Reds are in a dead heat for the NL Central lead. Milwaukee has won three straight series, including a four-gamer against the Mets earlier this week. Cincinnati’s lone blemish over the past four weeks is a series loss to the Braves two weekends ago. With Hunter Greene, Nick Lodolo, and now Ben Lively on the Injured List, the Reds have had to scramble to find arms to fill up their starting rotation. Thankfully, Alexis Díaz is leading a bullpen that has been surprisingly effective. These two teams are on a collision course over the next two weeks: they play three games this weekend in Milwaukee and then start the second half of the season with three games in Cincinnati.
Tier 4 – Up and Down
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Guardians
41-42
0
89
97
88
3
93
37.0%
Red Sox
43-42
-1
104
104
98
-23
83
18.5%
Cardinals
35-48
-4
107
108
102
-6
99
9.9%
Pirates
39-44
1
93
97
103
2
80
3.9%
Mets
38-46
-3
102
112
108
-6
72
11.7%
The Cardinals managed to win their weekend series with the Yankees but were thoroughly trounced by the Astros earlier in the week. They’re stuck in a middle ground where they’re not good enough to challenge for the NL Central crown but have got too much talent on their roster to be at the bottom of the division. Jordan Walker’s success since being recalled from Triple-A is a positive sign, but this team desperately needs an infusion of new talent on the mound.
Things have gotten so bad for the Mets that owner Steve Cohen held a press conference last week to address the team’s struggles. While the message ultimately ended up being “stay the course,” they’re quickly running out of time to fix things. It’s unlikely they’ll make any big acquisitions at the trade deadline, so any improvement will have to come from the players already on the team. They did manage to beat the Giants over the weekend, which is a small step in the right direction, but they’ve still got a lot of ground to make up. They’ll wrap up the first half of the season with a West Coast road trip that takes them through Arizona and San Diego.
Tier 5 – Hope Deferred
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Tigers
37-46
3
88
110
99
3
55
2.4%
Nationals
34-49
0
93
106
117
-3
51
0.0%
White Sox
37-49
0
91
105
111
-7
43
5.1%
Royals
25-59
-4
82
119
107
9
48
0.0%
Rockies
33-53
2
81
128
101
-16
16
0.0%
Athletics
23-63
1
88
143
135
-8
15
0.0%
The Royals showed some life over the weekend, winning two of three from the Dodgers to log their first series win since mid-May and their first back-to-back victories since May 28–29. They also kicked off trade season by sending Aroldis Chapman to the Rangers on Friday. They don’t have many more top prospects on the verge of the majors at this point, and their farm system is devoid of top end talent now that they’ve graduated Bobby Witt Jr., Vinnie Pasquantino, and MJ Melendez. That means the rest of this season should be focused on seeing if any of those young players can take a big step forward developmentally.
…
Complete Power Rankings
Rank
Team
Record
“Luck”
wRC+
SP-
RP-
RAA
Team Quality
Playoff Odds
Δ
1
Braves
56-27
2
123
90
84
-6
160
100.0%
2
2
Rays
57-30
-1
126
88
102
6
161
99.3%
-1
3
Rangers
50-34
-6
122
87
101
11
170
81.7%
-1
4
Diamondbacks
50-35
4
105
101
95
8
134
79.8%
1
5
Astros
46-38
-2
102
92
91
8
139
64.9%
5
6
Blue Jays
45-40
1
108
96
92
3
142
56.6%
0
7
Giants
46-38
0
103
99
93
11
138
67.9%
-3
8
Dodgers
46-37
-1
110
100
102
0
124
89.3%
-1
9
Orioles
49-33
6
104
105
87
-10
103
61.3%
-1
10
Angels
45-41
-1
113
100
95
0
133
33.9%
-1
11
Yankees
46-38
1
96
104
80
5
102
64.8%
4
12
Phillies
44-39
2
101
90
95
-5
117
55.1%
6
13
Marlins
48-37
8
97
90
99
-7
89
64.7%
3
14
Padres
38-46
-7
101
91
98
17
135
22.0%
-3
15
Mariners
40-42
-3
100
95
96
9
127
15.8%
-2
16
Twins
42-43
-4
98
83
90
-13
107
58.6%
-2
17
Cubs
38-44
-5
99
94
90
4
122
10.6%
-5
18
Brewers
45-39
5
86
99
99
15
85
59.6%
4
19
Reds
45-39
5
98
112
96
-10
58
25.6%
-2
20
Guardians
41-42
0
89
97
88
3
93
37.0%
1
21
Red Sox
43-42
-1
104
104
98
-23
83
18.5%
-2
22
Cardinals
35-48
-4
107
108
102
-6
99
9.9%
-2
23
Pirates
39-44
1
93
97
103
2
80
3.9%
0
24
Mets
38-46
-3
102
112
108
-6
72
11.7%
0
25
Tigers
37-46
3
88
110
99
3
55
2.4%
0
26
Nationals
34-49
0
93
106
117
-3
51
0.0%
1
27
White Sox
37-49
0
91
105
111
-7
43
5.1%
-1
28
Royals
25-59
-4
82
119
107
9
48
0.0%
0
29
Rockies
33-53
2
81
128
101
-16
16
0.0%
0
30
Athletics
23-63
1
88
143
135
-8
15
0.0%
0